• Peer Team Resources

The resources gathered here for members of peer review teams include all the core information we consider important to your understanding of the various pieces of the accreditation experience from the peer reviewer team member perspective. Here you will find guides to help you navigate the accreditation experience, relevant policies, reports used for data gathering, templates and samples of related documents and more.

You can refine your search by resource type, topic, review type, or keyword. As you update your search details the resources below will adjust automatically. To explore all resources, regardless of the audience, use the main resource page.

FEATURED | HANDBOOK

2023 Handbook of Accreditation

The WSCUC 2023 Handbook provides information on the 2023 Standards, the Institutional Review Process for Reaffirmation, and Commission Decisions.

FEATURED | PROCESS

Evidence and Data

This page provides access to data on WSCUC accredited institutions, information about WSCUC data initiatives such as peer benchmarking, and highlights of WSCUC’s “Better Conversations, Better Data” initiative.

FEATURED | PROCESS

Key Indicators Dashboard

The Key Indicators Dashboard (KID) presents detailed trend and comparative information on WSCUC’s accredited undergraduate and graduate institutions in a clear, easy to use format. KID displays from federal data sets to present multiple years of metrics, trend data, and comparisons based on both national and WSCUC averages. KID provides integrated, accessible data on institution size and context, student completion, student finances, institution finances, and post-graduation outcomes.

FEATURED | PROCESS

Substantive Change Resources

Information on how institutions need to report and seek approval of changes to their mission, educational programs, scope, control or organizational structure.

FEATURED | PROCESS

Volunteer Information Portal (VIP) Login

The Volunteer Information Portal (VIP) is for Peer Reviewers and other volunteers in our community. A person’s VIP account allows them to: create and update their profile; share areas of expertise and necessary details to be considered for future volunteer opportunities; view current team information and see peer reviewer history via My Teams; and access the Key Indicators Dashboard (KID).

PROCESS

About the Volunteer Information Portal (VIP)

The Volunteer Information Portal (VIP) is for Peer Reviewers and other volunteers in our community. A person’s VIP account allows them to: create and update their profile; share areas of expertise and necessary details to be considered for future volunteer opportunities; view current team information and see peer reviewer history via My Teams; and access the Key Indicators Dashboard (KID).

WORKSHOPS & TRAINING MATERIALS

About WSCUC ARC

WSCUC’s Accreditation Resource Conference (ARC) is an annual gathering of WSCUC and the broader higher education community that focuses on issues of critical importance and features presentations and content geared towards accreditation and institutional improvement.

REPORT

About WSCUC’s Key Indicators Dashboard (KID)

This document provides an overview of Key Indicators Dashboard (KID), including a description of the dashboard, the content, and how the dashboard is used as part of the accreditation process.

PROCESS

Accreditation Policy & Procedure Committee (AP&P)

Roles and responsibilities of the Commission's Accreditation Policy & Procedure Committee.

WORKSHOPS & TRAINING MATERIALS

Accreditation Resource Conference (ARC)

WSCUC’s Accreditation Resource Conference (ARC) is an annual gathering of WSCUC and the broader higher education community that focuses on issues of critical importance and features presentations and content geared towards accreditation and institutional improvement.

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Accreditation Visit (AV) and Seeking Accreditation Visit (SAV) Remote Review Schedule – Sample

A sample of the schedule an ALO completes as a draft and presents it to the team chair and WSCUC staff seven weeks before the remote review.

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Accreditation Visit (AV) and Seeking Accreditation Visit (SAV) Schedule – Sample

This spreadsheet provides a sample schedule of meetings for visits.

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Accreditation Visit (AV) Chair Communication to Team – Sample

2023 Handbook: This sample email template is for use by the visit chair in the initial communication to team members.

FORM

Accreditation Visit (AV) Confidential Team Recommendation Form

This form is used by Accreditation Visit teams to convey its recommendation to the Commission.

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Accreditation Visit (AV) Team Report Directions and Template

2023 Handbook: These directions and template are for use by the visiting team when preparing the team report.

WORKSHEET

Accreditation Visit (AV) Team Worksheet

2023 Handbook: This worksheet is for use by teams to assist in reviewing the institution’s report and identifying key issues for the accreditation visit.

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Accreditation Visit (AV) Videoconference Agenda – Sample

This provides a sample agenda for the first review team videoconference meeting for an Accreditation Visit.

PROCESS

Appeals Committee

Role of the Commission's Appeals Committee.

POLICY

Artificial Intelligence in Accreditation Policy – Principles and Restrictions

In the rapidly evolving landscape of education and technology, the use of artificial intelligence (AI) presents both opportunities and challenges for the accreditation process.

GUIDES & MANUALS

Assistant Chair Role and Responsibilities Guide

This guide describes the responsibilities of an institution accreditation team’s assistant chair in providing support for the team and chair throughout the accreditation process.

PROCESS

Audit Committee

Roles and responsibilities of the Commission's Audit Committee.

POLICY

Commission Bylaws

The formal bylaws adopted by the Commission describe its governance structure.

PROCESS

Compensation Committee

Roles and responsibilities of the Commission's Compensation Committee.

FORM

Complaint Form

This form is used to submit a complaint to WSCUC and includes the submission instructions and links to relevant policy documents.

POLICY

Complaints and Third-Party Comments Policy

WSCUC has two established means for receiving comments from concerned stakeholders about its member institutions: complaints and third-party comments. This document describes the WSCUC policy related to complaints and third-party comments as it pertains to member institutions and other parties in the process.

HANDBOOK

Compliance with WSCUC Standards Worksheet

2023 Handbook: This worksheet serves two purposes: 1) To provide reviewers ready access to evidence that the institution is in compliance with Commission Standards 2) To prompt conversation within the institution regarding institutional capacity and infrastructure, strengths, weaknesses, priorities, and plans for ensuring compliance with the Standards.

POLICY

Conflict of Interest Policy

This policy describes the duty to avoid conflicts of interest and the appearance of conflicts of interest applying to all participants in the accreditation process pertaining to an institution. This includes individuals who are selected to serve on review teams, Commissioners, committee and panel members, working group members, staff members, consultants, and any other individual who acts on behalf of the Commission. It complements Commission expecations related to ethical conduct.

FORM

Credit Hour Review Form

One of four forms that WSCUC uses to address institutional compliance with federal regulations, this form is completed by teams in evaluating the reliability and accuracy of the institution's assignment of credit hours. During the Accreditation Visit, teams complete this form and add it as an appendix to the Team Report.

REPORT

Data Definitions for Key Indicators (KI) Reports

The KI Fields and Definitions dictionary provides definitions of the KI data elements and documents the sources of the data.

FORM

Distance Education Review Form

A completed copy of this form should be appended to the team report for all comprehensive visits to institutions that offer distance education programs and for other visits as applicable.

GUIDES & MANUALS

Distance Education Review Guide

2023 Handbook: Under federal regulations, WSCUC is required to demonstrate that distance education programs are reviewed during the comprehensive accreditation/reaffirmation process. This guide details specific elements to be included in upcoming reviews, to ensure that each team is reviewing distance education programs in a consistent manner.

GUIDES & MANUALS

Drafting Preliminary Team Report Narrative Guide

This guide provides suggestions for team members when drafting the preliminary team report prior to the visit.

WORKSHOPS & TRAINING MATERIALS

Educational Programs & Training

WSCUC offers a variety of educational programming to help expand the skills of our community, including the Accreditation Resource Conference (ARC), the Assessment Leadership Academy (ALA), and webinars and workshops on various relevant topics.

PROCESS

Executive Committee (EC)

Roles and responsibilities of the Commission's Executive Committee.

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Executive Session Agenda – Sample

A sample agenda for the review team to follow in the Executive Session meeting prior to the site visit.

FORM

Expense Reimbursement Form

Representatives of WSCUC submit this form for reimbursement out-of-pocket expenses incurred while attending meetings of the Commission, when serving on accreditation review teams, or performing other assigned duties.

FORM

Federal Compliance Forms

There are four forms that WSCUC uses to address institutional compliance with some of the federal regulation’s affecting institutions and accrediting agencies. During the visit, teams complete these four forms and add them as an appendix to the Team Report.

PROCESS

Finance & Operations Committee (F&O)

Roles and responsibilities of the Commission's Finance & Operations Committee.

POLICY

Gifts Policy

The policy for WSCUC staff, peer evaluators, and commissioners related to the receipt of gifts from eligible, candidate, and accredited institutions.

PROCESS

Governance Committee

Roles and responsibilities of the Commission's Governance Committee.

GUIDES & MANUALS

Guide: KID Carnegie Custom Peer Selection Tool

A step-by-step guide to building custom Carnegie peer groups in the Key Indicators Dashboard

GUIDES & MANUALS

How to Become Accredited Guide

The How to Become Accredited Guide describes the level of readiness expected of the institution at each step as it moves through Eligibility.

POLICY

Institutional Response to Team Report Policy

WSUC has traditionally invited and included institutional responses to team reports in Commission materials for review of institutions. This policy establishes that such communications are officially part of the institutional record, complying with Department of Education requirements.

PROCESS

Interim Report Committee

The Interim Report Committee (IRC) reviews Interim Reports and supporting documents that have been requested by the Commission.

WORKSHEET

Interim Report Committee (IRC) Evaluation Worksheet

Worksheet used by the Interim Report Committee (IRC) when evaluating a proposal.

PROCESS

International Accreditation Committee (IAC)

Roles and responsibilities of the Commission's International Accreditation Committee.

WORKSHOPS & TRAINING MATERIALS

Key Indicators (KI) Tip Sheet for Teams

The KI Tip Sheets for Teams provides tips for how to use Key Indicators (KI) reports as part of an accreditation review, general questions to consider when reviewing and discussing the KI data, and specific questions related to the CFRs

WEBINAR

Making It Real: Data in a Time of Crisis – Adaptations and Innovations

An exploration of data’s integral place in institutional self-assessment and accreditation peer review. WSCUC President Jamienne S. Studley and Vice President Stephanie Huie engage in conversation with quality and evidence superstars Amelia Parnell and Archie P. Cubarrubia.

FORM

Marketing and Recruitment Review Form

This form is completed by review teams to demonstrate the monitoring of an institution’s recruiting and admissions practices, in compliance with federal regulations.

GUIDES & MANUALS

Methods for Gathering Information and Evidence during Institutional Visits Guide

This guide is intended to help team members prepare for meetings with institutional representatives and ask questions that will result in useful information.

PROCESS

Nominating Committee (NC)

The Commission's Nominating Committee membership.

POLICY

Notices of Required Information Policy

This policy describes the Commission's responsibility to notify the Secretary of Education of proposed changes in policies, procedures, or accreditation standards that would alter its status or scope of recognition or might alter compliance with the criteria for recognition.

FORM

Observers on Peer Review Teams Agreement Form

This confidentiality agreement form must be completed by observers on peer review teams.

POLICY

Observers on Peer Review Teams Policy

The policy concerning the presence of observers on peer review teams.

FORM

Off-Campus Locations Review Form

2023 Handbook: This form should be completed and included as an appendix to the team report for all visits in which off-campus sites were reviewed. One form should be used for each site visited.

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Offsite Review (OSR) Chair Communication to the Team – Sample

2023 Handbook: This template is for use by the team chair in the initial communication to team members prior to the Offsite Review (OSR).

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Offsite Review (OSR) Schedule – Sample

2023 Handbook: A sample schedule for use by peer review teams participating in an Offsite Review (OSR).

GUIDES & MANUALS

Offsite Review (OSR) Summary of Lines of Inquiry Guide

This form is to be completed by the team at the conclusion of its daylong Offsite Review of the institutional report and supporting materials. The form will be sent to the institution within one week by the WSCUC liaison, and a response to section IV will be sent back from the institution eight weeks in advance of the Accreditation Visit

WORKSHEET

Offsite Review (OSR) Team Worksheet

2023 Handbook: This worksheet is used by teams to assist in reviewing the institution's report and identifying key issues for the Offsite Review (OSR).

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Offsite Review (OSR) Timeline for Remote Review Template

An overview of the timeline and process for peer review teams participating in the remote offsite review, including the actions to be taken by team members, WSCUC staff, and the institution before, during, and after the remote offsite review (OSR).

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Offsite Review (OSR) Videoconference Agenda – Sample

2023 Handbook: This agenda suggests the topics to be covered by the team in advance of the conduct of the Offsite Review.

GUIDES & MANUALS

Offsite Review (OSR) Videoconference with Institutional Representatives Guide

This guide describes the Offsite Review Videoconference with institutional representatives, including the purpose, participants, format and content of the call.

GUIDES & MANUALS

Onsite Visit Logistics for Team Members Guide

This Guide describes the visit logistics for Accreditation Visit, Seeking Accreditation Visit & Special Visit team members, including the team roster, travel and hotel arrangements, and reimbursement.

GUIDES & MANUALS

Peer Benchmarking Guide

Guide to peers & benchmarking in WSCUC's Key Indicators Dashboard (KID).

PROCESS

Peer Reviewer Interest Form

This form is to be filled out by individuals who wish to be considered to serve as a peer reviewer on future accreditation reviews.

PROCESS

Peer Reviewers

The strength and success of WSCUC’s peer review process depend on the generous contribution of insight, effort, and time by hundreds of dedicated volunteers. Learn more about or express interest in volunteering.

GUIDES & MANUALS

Periods of Accreditation Guide

This guide explains the rationale for the various periods of accreditation granted by the Commission after an Accreditation visit.

PROCESS

Public Comments & Complaints

WSCUC has two established means for receiving comments from concerned stakeholders about its member institutions: complaints and third-party comments. This page describes the role of WSCUC in relation to the complaints and third-party comments process with links to relevant policies and forms.

POLICY

Review of Commission Standards Policy

This policy describes the Commission’s practice of regularly reviewing and reaffirming the Standards of Accreditation and the process by which changes to the Standards are proposed..

GUIDES & MANUALS

Seeking Accreditation Compliance Guide

2023 Handbook: The Seeking Accreditation Compliance guide is not a formula or analog by which a team will arrive at a mathematically precise determination. It is a tool to narrow the ambiguity inherent in making a complex, holistic judgment. Evaluators should complete the Guide individually then share their appraisal in a consensus-building session at the conclusion of the site visit.

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Seeking Accreditation Visit (SAV) 1 Team Report Directions and Template

These directions and template are for use by the visiting team when preparing the team report for a seeking accreditation 1 visit.

WORKSHEET

Seeking Accreditation Visit (SAV) 1 Team Worksheet

2023 Handbook: This worksheet is for use by accreditation teams to assist in reviewing the institution's report and identifying key issues for the seeking accreditation visit 1.

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Seeking Accreditation Visit (SAV) 2+ Team Report Directions and Template

These directions and template are for use by the visiting team when preparing the team report for a seeking accreditation 2 visit.

WORKSHEET

Seeking Accreditation Visit (SAV) 2+ Team Worksheet

This worksheet is for use by accreditation teams to assist in reviewing the institution's report and identifying key issues for the seeking accreditation visit 2.

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Seeking Accreditation Visit (SAV) Chair Communication to Team – Sample

2023 Handbook: This template is for use by the visit chair in the initial communication to team members prior to a Seeking Accreditation Visit.

FORM

Seeking Accreditation Visit (SAV) Confidential Team Recommendation Form

This form is used by teams to convey the recommendation to the Commission following a Seeking Accreditation Visit.

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Seeking Accreditation Visit (SAV) Videoconference Agenda – Template

This provides a sample agenda for the visiting team videoconference call for a Seeking Accreditation Visit

POLICY

Sharing Information with Other Agencies and Regard for their Decisions Policy

The policy concerning information sharing with other accrediting agencies, state agencies, the United States Department of Education (USDE), and other international agencies relevant to the institution.

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Special Visit (SV) Chair Communication to the Team – Sample

This template is for use by the visit chair in the initial communication to team members prior to a Special Visit.

FORM

Special Visit (SV) Confidential Team Recommendation Form

This form is used by teams to convey the recommendation to the Commission following a Special Visit.

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Special Visit (SV) Remote Review Schedule – Sample

The ALO completes this sample schedule as a draft and presents it to the team chair and WSCUC staff seven weeks before the remote review. Session times will vary, as will the individuals and groups with whom the team meets. ALOs should consult the Planning the Visit section of the Visit Process Guide for more information on the schedule.

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Special Visit (SV) Schedule – Sample

The ALO completes this sample Special Visit schedule as a draft and presents it to the team chair and WSCUC staff seven weeks before the visit. Session times will vary, as will the individuals and groups with whom the team meets. ALOs should consult the Planning the Visit section of the Visit Process Guide for more information on the schedule.

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Special Visit (SV) Team Report Directions and Template

These directions and template are for use by the visiting team when preparing the team report for a special visit.

WORKSHEET

Special Visit (SV) Team Worksheet

This worksheet is for use by review teams to assist in reviewing the institution's report and identifying key issues for the special visit.

FORM

Special Visit (SV) to Institution on Sanction Confidential Team Recommendation Form

Recommendation from the team to the Commission for an institution on a sanction or Notice of Concern

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Special Visit (SV) Videoconference Call Agenda – Sample

This provides a sample agenda for the first visiting team videoconference call for a Special Visit.

FORM

Standards of Conduct Confidentiality and Conflict of Interest Policy Disclosure Form

This form is signed by Commission members, Committee members, review team members, professional staff, and other representatives of the Commission to denote agreement with the Commission’s Conflict of Interest Policy and ethical conduct expectations and confirm the disclosure of all potential Conflicts of Interest.

PROCESS

Structural Change Committee (SC)

Roles and responsibilities of the Commission's Structural Change Committee.

FORM

Student Complaints Review Form

Teams complete this form to document the review of the institution’s student complaints policies, procedures, and records in accordance with federal regulation.

GUIDES & MANUALS

Student Outcomes Overview – a Brief Guide

This document helps users understand the Student Outcomes Overview (SOO) by providing tips for reviewing the SOO, general questions to ask when considering the data, and an overview of the metrics included. The SOO is a one page summary of student outcomes data compared to peers and national values for WSCUC accredited institutions that serve undergraduates.

GUIDES & MANUALS

Student Outcomes Overview (SOO) Narrative Preparation Instructions

This document provides instructions for institutions to prepare the SOO narrative. SOO narratives demonstrate an understanding of student outcomes performance and demonstrate a proactive approach to improvement.

PROCESS

Substantive Change Committee

Responsibilities of the Substantive Change Peer Review Committee.

GUIDES & MANUALS

Substantive Change Follow-up Site Visit Guidelines and Checklist

This guide describes the Substantive Change follow-up visit and provides the report template for teams to submit to WSCUC after the visit.

GUIDES & MANUALS

Substantive Change Pre-Approval Site Visit Guide

This guide describes the Substantive Change pre-approval site visit and the template for the visit report

GUIDES & MANUALS

Team Chair Role and Responsibilities Guide

This guide describes the role and responsibilities of an institution review team’s chair as part of the institutional review process.

GUIDES & MANUALS

Team Member Role and Responsibilities Guide

This guide describes the role and responsibilities of an institution review team’s members as part of the institutional review process.

GUIDES & MANUALS

Team Report Preparation and Confidentiality of Information Guide

This memo concerns the transparency of information and reports following the review of an institution, describing the type of information that will be publicly available versus the information that will remain confidential.

WORKSHOPS & TRAINING MATERIALS

Tips for Teams for Conducting Remote Reviews

A list of suggestions and tips for teams conducting a remote review using videoconference and other virtual communication. Topics include virtual meeting etiquette and what to do before, during, and after the review.

GUIDES & MANUALS

Tools and Requirements for Review Teams Guide

This guide contains descriptions of the various documents that may apply to an upcoming review and links to these documents on the WSCUC website.

POLICY

Training Peer Reviewers Policy

WSCUC has traditionally provided training to peer reviewers on its standards and procedures for reviews of institutions. This policy officially codifies the training of WSCUC’s peer reviewers, ensuring compliance with federal regulations.

FORM

Transfer Credit Review Form

Under federal regulations, WSCUC is required to demonstrate that it monitors the institution’s transfer credit policy and practices. This form is to be completed by teams during the review process.

POLICY

Travel and Business Expense Policy

This policy applies to all persons seeking reimbursement for travel and business expenses incurredin conducting WSCUC business.

GUIDES & MANUALS

Understanding the 2023 Standards

The Understanding the 2023 WSCUC Standards provides material to help facilitate an institution’s self-evaluation under the Standards; this document complements and expands the instructions in the 2023 Handbook of Accreditation and should be used in conjunction with the Handbook.

TEMPLATES & SAMPLES

Visit Timeline Template

An overview of the timeline and process for peer review teams participating in an accreditation visit, seeking accreditation visit, or special visit, including the actions to be taken by team members, WSCUC staff, and the institution before, during, and after the visit.

PROCESS

Where to Find Data on WSCUC Institutions

Explore publicly collected, standardized data about WSCUC-accredited institutions.

GUIDES & MANUALS

WSCUC Style Guide

The purpose of this guide is to help institutions, team members, and staff members write reports following the WSCUC editorial style and usage conventions.